This is the response of Rajendra Prasad Garu on 'Islam mariyu nenu' article
"Mr, Khuddus, I have read your article. It contains many logical questions. Any number of questions questions can be framed against Quran for which nobody can answer and nobody other than the God himself is empowered to answer. Firstly God should have declared like the following. "I am God. There was nothing else except me when I was born. I am existing of my own desire without anybodies interference. For some time in my life I was alone and hence everything was good and there was nothing like bad. I had no work and I was simply wasting time. I was bored of sitting idle for five crore billion years or more which I have not counted. Hence I thought of creating some work for me. After thinking for ten thousand billion years I decided to make use of my talent and thus I started creation of this universe just for time pass. In the process I thought of creating living beings like toys and play with them. My object of creation is nothing but to entertain myself with the help of my capabilities. Since I have not experienced any trouble in my long life I have no knowledge of how the trouble is. Hence I am playing with the lives created by me. I want to tell you all as to how you should behave during your life. But unfortunately I am not capable of appearing before you. And I am not capable of writing or making a book on what I want to tell you. Hence I have selected a person among you who is also illiterate like me to spread my message. There is a reason for Why I selected an illiterate person. The reason is that literates will be wise and they keep questioning me for which I have no answers. I know only one language."
Here comes my response on this:
Mr, Khuddus, I have read your article. It contains many logical
questions. Any number of questions questions can be framed against Quran
for which nobody can answer and nobody other than the God himself is
empowered to answer.
Khuddus: Sir I know that even though these questions are addressing God, he couldn't answer from my Experiences. I had so many people, my friends, relatives and many people who are part of my society believing that Quran is word of God. I've posed these questions, to arise a thought in them. I'm just expecting them to change their way of thought or change my way of thought by showing what is truth.
Firstly God should have declared like
the following. "I am God. There was nothing else except me when I was
born. I am existing of my own desire without anybodies interference. For
some time in my life I was alone and hence everything was good and
there was nothing like bad. I had no work and I was simply wasting time.
I was bored of sitting idle for five crore billion years or more which I
have not counted. Hence I thought of creating some work for me. After
thinking for ten thousand billion years I decided to make use of my
talent and thus I started creation of this universe just for time pass.
In the process I thought of creating living beings like toys and play
with them. My object of creation is nothing but to entertain myself with
the help of my capabilities. Since I have not experienced any trouble
in my long life I have no knowledge of how the trouble is. Hence I am
playing with the lives created by me. I want to tell you all as to how
you should behave during your life. But unfortunately I am not capable
of appearing before you. And I am not capable of writing or making a
book on what I want to tell you. Hence I have selected a person among
you who is also illiterate like me to spread my message. There is a
reason for Why I selected an illiterate person. The reason is that
literates will be wise and they keep questioning me for which I have no
answers. I know only one language."
Khuddus: After reading this I've came to a conclusion that you're addressing the God of Quran, Allah in this portion. You've posed questions in satirical manner, which brought some smiles on my face. Your writing raised some good Logical questions, but along with some logical errors according to Quran.
Firstly I'll describe errors
Firstly I'll describe errors
1. God is not born according to Quran
2. There is nothing like five crore billion years of definite time before creation. It is just infinite time.
3. The reason for creation is not for TimePass because he passed infinite time before creation.
4.God has knowledge of even trouble, because Allah is all-knowing according to Quran.
3. The reason for creation is not for TimePass because he passed infinite time before creation.
4.God has knowledge of even trouble, because Allah is all-knowing according to Quran.
5.God is even capable of appearing before us, because Allah is all-capable
6.God knows all languages
Good Logical Questions arised after reading your article are:
1.** For any person to move or in order to start a work, one should have to feel unpleasantness in the current position. What is the unpleasantness does the God faced in order to start the process of creation?(You've said boring is unpleasantness, but it wouldn't be the cause because he have passed infinite time without any boring). This is a fundamental question that needs to be answered by creationists.
Good Logical Questions arised after reading your article are:
1.** For any person to move or in order to start a work, one should have to feel unpleasantness in the current position. What is the unpleasantness does the God faced in order to start the process of creation?(You've said boring is unpleasantness, but it wouldn't be the cause because he have passed infinite time without any boring). This is a fundamental question that needs to be answered by creationists.
2. Even though he knows the trouble, or pain why he has created Hell to burn people? Do he enjoy people burning there?
3. Why he's selecting prophets to give us knowledge about him, while he's directly capable of?
Thank you,
3. Why he's selecting prophets to give us knowledge about him, while he's directly capable of?
Thank you,
Regards,
Abdul Khuddus
Comments
Post a Comment